Do or don't: Boat shoes this fall

What kind of shoes do you wear in the fall? I usually wear flats, but I'm hoping for a new look. So I was psyched to see these boat shoes on Tomboy Style. They're cool and tomboy-ish, and I've spotted super chic women wearing them around New York. Thoughts? Would you wear them?

From top: Bass, $119; L.L. Bean Signature, $69; L.L. Bean, $49; Bass, $119.

(By the fantastic Tomboy Style)