Pop Coloured Eyelids: Thumbs up or down?

I'm terrible when it comes to applying eye makeup and probably that is why I stick to my good friend, the red lipstick most of the time. Having said that, I'm utterly intrigued with the new trend that is everywhere right now - the colour popped lids . It seems that ladies all around the globe are swapping their black eyeliner for this unexpected pop of bright eye-shadow onto their top lid.

I'm torn, but what do you think? Would you try this look? Have you already? What pop of colour would you go with? xo

P.S: If you fancy trying it, here is the how to.
P.P.S: Also, three snazzy ways to va va voom.

(Photos via Dilly Dallas and Free People)